This Is Silly
#3917 posted by negke on 2017/12/14 17:02:29
Speedmapping is good. But let's be honest, the theme is really just about calling someone out for having a different taste and being opinionated about it. Even if they may be inconsistent or whatever, his comments state what he liked or disliked and they don't come off as trollish like some others on the site. Putting a highlight on this by means of using it as an official speedmapping theme blows it out of proportion -it's a non-issue after all- and serves to prove his point on how everyone seems to be expected to have a generally positive opinion on maps. I get that this isn't meant to be overly serious, but still feels below us.
Meaning
#3918 posted by negke on 2017/12/14 17:11:26
Calling it "A map that someone with a highly refined taste can enjoy" would be more appropriate while keeping the ironic undertone.
What's The Difference?
#3919 posted by skacky on 2017/12/14 18:38:33
Everyone knows who we're talking about either way.
#3920 posted by negke on 2017/12/14 19:07:02
The difference is not calling him directly by name and drawing attention, not on a personal level. Better as an inside joke.
Always trust negke to be a total killjoy.
America's Top Quake Map!
#3922 posted by Redfield on 2017/12/14 22:18:36
Well since it seems that REDACTED(the Quaddicted reviewer in question) = Simon Cowell then to avoid using anyones Quaddicted alias maybe call it:
-Maps for Simon Cowell
-American Idoljam
Rep-who??
#3923 posted by Shambler on 2017/12/14 23:12:39
And should I care about him?
@Shambler
exactly... this whole thing is strange, even for func
#3925 posted by muk on 2017/12/15 14:59:17
hey guys way to take just a totally light hearted jab at a jam and turn it into a psycho analysis of some random eastern European dude.
Bleh
Bloody obviously not better to make it a cutesy ironic inside joke, that comes off as underhanded and actually meaner than skacky's original intention.
Exotic his opinions may or may not be, he did straight up say his tastes are "more refined" than the rest of Quaddicted. If you put yourself on a pedestal you automatically open yourself to the possibility of becoming target practice.
Worst case scenario is that they don't like the speedmaps created.
Where?
#3927 posted by Cocerello on 2017/12/15 18:19:18
he did straight up say his tastes are "more refined" than the rest of Quaddicted
No matter how much i check his comments or the forum not only i can't see that, but nowhere about he talking about himself.
I went with the flow before and tried to redirect a bit the topic, but i have to say that this is getting out of hand, and just because a guy didn't like two popular releases.
Wait
#3928 posted by Zwiffle on 2017/12/15 18:23:42
So are we speedmapping or no?
#3929 posted by skacky on 2017/12/15 18:48:54
Nah, we're all bickering over pointless shit, as usual, and making me pass for a huge asshole because that's what func_ is about.
Hey, Atleast It's Not About Timezones Again.
#3930 posted by Danz on 2017/12/15 19:10:02
Wait
#3931 posted by Qmaster on 2017/12/15 22:32:04
So I should scrap my box room with one shambler?
10 Mins Remaining Folks
#3932 posted by skacky on 2017/12/15 23:51:04
Thanks To Both Mukor And Naitelveni Who Released A Map For This
#3933 posted by skacky on 2017/12/16 01:29:56
Congrats to Naitelveni especially who made a fun map in under four hours.
I don't thank the other few people who just like to endlessly complain, undermine community efforts and somehow know my intentions better than I do. I will not bother anymore. You know who you are.
@skacky @muk0r
Some of us weren't in on the joke, kinda felt left out. Also, there's another Jam going on and people are using their limited spare time to work on that. Myself included.
@Muk This is a demo I did at work. Pretty derpy. Not used to mac keyboard and Quake. I want to play it again. It's gorgeous. This is from the file you posted on Discord.
http://www.quaketastic.com/files/demos/sm180_mukor1.dem.zip
#3935 posted by muk on 2017/12/16 02:57:51
Thanks for the demo! Sorry about the health pack in a spot you cant reach it. i didnt think that one through obviously! lol
A Request To Skacky/Naitelveni/mukor/Shambler
I usually try to keep out of Func drama and I don't mean to tread on any toes with this, but here goes --
I have a lot of respect and appreciation for Skacky's, Naitelveni's and mukor's work, and I am not saying it was anybody's intention to be mean. And though I basically share the sentiments of post #3917, I respect the fact people have different opinions on the matter, and if the "joke" is something people found cathartic/funny/something that inspired them to map, then I guess it's served a useful purpose -- but then can we please leave it at that, as a joke that exists in the Func Speedmapping thread?
The problem is that regardless of intent, as it stands the name of the pack still comes across as mean-spirited. Explicitly mocking people who are not part of the Func mapping community and are just playing maps on Quaddicted seems like a good way to alienate players and sets a really bad precedent.
So can the title of sm180_pack in the release thread please be renamed to "unthemed" (seeing as they are essentially two unthemed maps anyway)?
It's only explicit mocking if for whatever internalised reason you choose to interpret it as explicit mocking.
It's really hard to see how it can be read any other way: it calls out a particular commenter on Quaddicted by name. It's not someone who has requested a map pack like this, nor someone any of the authors have been in conversation with about creating a map pack.
So when suddenly, a speedmap pack pops up with the title "Maps that [this person] can enjoy", it certainly doesn't come across as genuine -- especially given the fact that the commenter in question has expressed opinions that deviate from the popular consensus (and has on at least one occasion received an uncalled-for snooty response).
#3939 posted by muk on 2017/12/18 16:55:16
Its worth noting that the uncalled for snooty response wasnt from anyone on func. OTP and skacky spoke in defense of repus. (Sepulcher review)
I put a lot of time into my map. Hope he likes it.
Repus Guest
2 December 2017, 10:35
Well, Mr. Guest (couldn't think of something less banal for the nickname?), I actually did wrote positive comments on some levels, for example The Canal, and I actually do know what goes into map making, 'cause I created a level of my own back in early 2000's.
Your statement about only negative comments shows that you haven't downloaded many levels from this resource, otherwise you would definitely find some positive feedback.
There are no rules on this website allowing only positive comments, and the fact that I don't like some levels that the majority of people adore is, perhaps, I have better refined taste and I don't follow the crowd that just likes 95% of what is posted over here. That's too bad for me, 'cause it's hard for me to find a level to enjoy.
https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/ion01.html
How's that for an uncalled-for snooty response??
I Mean He Says It Himself Right There.
it's hard for me to find a level to enjoy.
|