* Ptoing:
- Purplebrick: looks good, with a strong personality. I'm also waiting to see a purple texture set, and if there is a orange and pink ones, even better.
As Fifth said, i also see that they aren't very Quakeish. It's good because that gives us the option to make maps with a different feeling, but most mappers prefer to make Quakeish maps for Quake, so it can affect how many people will use them.
Something that had bugged me is that in my eyes those are blocks, more than bricks, at least in size. Apart from the size, i can't tell for sure if that is stone or brick.
In Quake, bricks are usually smaller (8-12 units high), like ID's city1_x and city 2_x textures. Check Quake e4m7 for reference.
Don't misunderstand me. It is good to have bricks so big, but it is probably better if bricks so big aren't common in the texture set, except if that is one of the charms of the set, if it is like that, ignore what i said about their size and keep going like that.
- Weirdrocktest: looks good as well, as a desert rock texture, but the tiling is a bit obvious: In a normal texture that wouldn't be much of an issue, but rock textures are often used outdoors, where most brushes are well and homogeneously lit, very big and you see them from afar, so the tiling is way more noticiable (in this case, the whitish zone in the upper-left corner).
Try to make all rock textures at least 128x128 and make some 256x256 or maybe 512x512, and check that there is no point in them that stands out noticiably (in this case probably getting rid of the whitish zone is probably enough).
Well, most of those tips are in
Rorshach tutorials(at the bottom of the page), so it is probably better if you read them directly than me continuing to write.
*Hipshot: looks decent for a first try. It would need something around the door, a frame, or better, some rockish detail.
Glad you are coming back to the dark side of mapping ;) .