News | Forum | People | FAQ | Links | Search | Register | Log in
Modern Retro Shooters / Quake Spiritual Successors
Wonder If A Specific Retro-shooter Thread Is Warranted?
#10166 posted by Shambler [92.29.26.135] on 2017/08/27 11:32:00


It is! Separate thread because there's a lot of these sort of games, the ethos of them is particularly relevant to this board, and it's inhabitants seem to have some good varying opinions on the matter.

Quake as the eptiome as 90s action FPS:

Very direct control and physics
Simple streamlined gameplay
Brutal visceral and gory
Weird fantasy / gothic / industrial theme
Grungy, coherent graphics
Cool map designs / architecture (for the time)
Varied but consistent bestiary
Etc
(many of the above adhered to and greatly enhanced by subsequent custom content)

We all like these aspects, we all like these aspects in other games, we all want to see more of those games, possibly combined with modern graphical styles (Quake Chumpions MAPS might be an example of how far this could go) and maybe very limited modern additions (crouching? an inventory? coherent story? - but nothing that gets in the way of solid action). We perhaps want the next Quake / 90s action FPS spiritual successor...

Modern Retro Shooters:

...and lo, there's a neverending stream of modern retro games many of which are unabashedly marketting themselves as 90s action FPS spiritual successors and particularly highlighting speed, direct control, simple action, limitless violence. Do they have what it takes to hit that mark though??

Strafe
http://store.steampowered.com/app/442780/STRAFE_Millennium_Edition/

Amid Evil
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wo7X7b6pPng

Dusk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tsu9uDMlIMM

Hellbound
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CyabhVn1SfQ

Apocryph
http://store.steampowered.com/app/596240/Apocryph_an_oldschool_shooter/

Ion Maiden
https://twitter.com/voidpnt

Neverdead
http://store.steampowered.com/app/681000/NEVRDEAD/

Gorescript
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vpZ1Wa0OIoQ

Intrude
https://bagogames.com/intrude-review/

Hermodr
http://store.steampowered.com/app/490360/Hermodr/

Devil Daggers
http://store.steampowered.com/app/422970/Devil_Daggers/

Gibhard
http://www.gibhard.com

Revulsion
http://store.steampowered.com/app/719180/Revulsion/

Witchfire
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zqjNkdXT94

PLUS MANY MORE LINKED IN THE THREAD BELOW....

Without wanting to opine too much, there seems to be a general trend of possibly not hitting the mark despite some attempts to do so, with a huge variety in how much potential those attempts show, as well as how close these games are to realising the overall harmonious game quality of a typical best 90s action FPS. I.e. Some games seem to do some aspects right, but don't seem to get all the aspects in balance and appealing together.

Discuss....
First | Previous | Next | Last
But, On The Other Hand. 
Gloomwood demo.

Texture fidelity that makes Id1 look refined. Engine quality that makes Quakespasm look like Frostbite. Character and weapon models that barely deserve the term model...

...and yet it has a sense of place, atmosphere, and purposeful theme to it than warrants a place at the top the pissfall for design alone. If you can cope with the engine and model limitations (I probably can't), this demo really sets a good tone.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hcFfnHrtNxU 
The Relentless Quality Of Modern Retro FPSes Keeps Coming... 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tJVH8Ft5d5M A short one thing. Arguably not short enough. 
Is It 
not really a Quake mod or TC? It looks 100% like one, even the assets.

As a mod as it says in the video it would be decent to good, with some fixes to the AI.

Also, could you provide a link for it? I cannot find a single thing, neither as a mod or as a commercial videogame. 
HROT 
really looks like a Quake TC with a custom engine.

As rough as the graphics and audio are, I would rather play these quake-inspired maps than the wolf3d-inspired maps from your other recent videos. There are actual outdoor areas with room to circle strafe instead of endless linear box corridors everywhere.

and the steam page says they have "flushable toilets" 
 
HROT definitely requires a certain sensibility to the "eastern bloc oppressiveness" vibes.

The original Quake has a similar appeal, in a way I am unable to describe. 
Coce. 
Google HROT?

Also re: Queak inspiration, watch the last 20 seconds of the vid.... 
#440 
Did it, and found nothing, because in the video it is written HORT, not HROT. With Hrot it is easy. 
 
Queak inspiration, watch the last 20 seconds of the vid....

Yeah, the looks are different from iD maps, but the textures look 100% percent that they come from a Quake custom map. More than inspired, copied from a .wad found somewhere. 
Okay So.... 
https://youtu.be/1v_X2v255W0

RetroFPS REAL TALK and final Ultrashill thoughts. I'm done with this for now. 
@Shambler 
My two cents about retro games in 2020:

3D Realms is doing a great job with Wrath, Graven and Ion Fury. Recruiting veteran mappers to do what they do best.

New Blood, apart from Gloomwood (made by a veteran Thief custom-mapper), all other games in their catalog feels more like a satire of old-school games, they remind me of those joke-wads from Doom community. I don't like it. 
 
Gloomwood looks cool. More like a Thief-style stealth game than a true FPS. But it's surprising the janky model/animation quality doesnt seem to have improved at all since Dusk. I know its still a one-man or at least very limited team, but you'd think they could hire or commission a modeler with the money from Dusk. 
Tribal. 
Ion Fury....I wouldn't get on with the build engine and sprites, but definitely got a strong theme and purpose.

This...

New Blood, apart from Gloomwood (made by a veteran Thief custom-mapper), all other games in their catalog feels more like a satire of old-school games, they remind me of those joke-wads from Doom community. I don't like it.

...is spot on too. I got the same feeling scrolling through 90% of the Realms Deep stuff on Steam. 
Finally For Now. 
A request please:

If anyone does find any properly good / inspiring retro FPSes that are of the ilk that Tribal listed above, please do still link them with shots and gameplay footage etc. The concept is still valid... Thanks. 
@Shambler 
If you're looking to get really fucking mad, look up Effigy, Endless Hunger and Perilous Warp. Utter fucking tart that people DROOL over, it makes me seriously wonder what these people get out of these games. Do they just hear buzzwords and dribble out a gleeful response? It's baffling. 
See Above For Perilous Warp 
And see further down the Effigy comments list.... 
Effigy 
let's hope it is an alpha and the brushwork simple blockout and not something which seems to be even worse than Dusk. Also, i think someone linked a video to it here before. 
Prodeus EA 
One of the 0.5% of RetroFPSes to actually show some potential including an aesthetic "theme" and some actual "design" is in Early Access...

https://store.steampowered.com/app/964800/Prodeus/

Cheers vigil for linking it on Discord. 
TDDaz Seal Of Approval.... 
https://twitter.com/tdDaz/status/1326638392361226240

Gotta say, those shots show things like "theme" "atmosphere" "architecture" "harmony of aesthetics" and other such rarities. Even the hud is pretty tasteful. 
On Reflection. 
I've decided that Hard Reset, as minor and limited as it is, is a true retro-FPS.

Does it blend old skool simple / fast gameplay with modern production values??

Does it actually have a theme, purpose, design, satisfying weapons and a decent bestiary??

Yes to both.

It has many issues: Movement is a bit sluggish, enemies are a bit bullet-spongey, almost all the cool architecture is a pure un-visitable backdrop, it's very arenay in places and quite 2-D in others, and if you care about such things the inter-mission story / dialogue is beyond terrible, it's also pretty damn short including the DLC.

But I had fun with it. The double weapons and their plethoric upgrades are actually nicely done and fun, the enemies at least have a theme, the backdrops are really cool and the overall graphics are good.

https://store.steampowered.com/app/407810/Hard_Reset_Redux/ 
 
it's dirty cheap now on gog: https://www.gog.com/game/hard_reset_redux 
OTOH. 
Here's some utter TURD that has been ruining poor viewers' eyes on Discord recently:

https://youtu.be/BIOJ6QURT5k

Nail And Crescent aka we have one torch model and one SNG ripped off from Quake Chumps or somewhere and think that a load of box rooms and plain pillars are enough to make a game BECAUSE RTX. Minecraft HD-textured box-cow ahoy!


https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC9F6I4gpeaEGcPDIvFC82pA/videos

Psymmetry aka all the effects and none of the level design whatsoever. Snapmap ahoy!

https://store.steampowered.com/app/807900/Hellver/

Hellver aka a pre-alpha test for devil fucking daggers being played on the gameboy or a pocket fucking calculator. Eye prolapse of horror ahoy! 
 
Nail and Crescent is claiming to be still WIP and really just a pack of content to make quake1-style levels in Quake2RTX. So, it makes sense that they don't have much content to show yet and also that they don't have any real level design. Maybe it's not ready to make a whole trailer, though. 
 
And maybe they should just port quakespasm to RTX. 
 
They need a third party audit on all that goddamn specularity on every surface. 
 
Wow, that Hellver looks like it has EGA graphics or something.

Nail & Crescent looks like some bad case of everything looking like wet clay, look at those nail ammo boxes, it's like they are oily or greasy, oh god.

What do you say about Core Decay?

https://store.steampowered.com/app/1260940/Core_Decay/

Although it doesn't present itself as some Doom/Quake "romeric" shooter for "true warriors". And gameplay wise it seems different. 
 
Core Decay I have been following a little bit on twitter and I think it looks neat 
Yeah Seems To Have A Theme And Purpose To That One. 
Seem to recall enemies looking pretty naff tho. Haven't been following it closely. Feel free to post the latest media links if it seems worth it. 
Latest Media? 
Last thing that was released is the the announcement trailer below. Not seen much since.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wjAvdzQhPQc 
Quakecast Interview On Core Decay 
This is before Ivar got the publishing deal but lot's of info.

https://quakecast.podbean.com/e/quakecast-47-ivar-hill-core-decay/ 
OCRUD 
Core Decay looks interesting, but from that footage, it also appears to have a mild case of what I call OCRUD (Obsessive Customization Requiring Upgrades Disorder) which is what most modern games suffer from (including a lot of retro-wannabes.)

In my opinion, if an FPS has OCRUD, it fails the "retroness" test due to "simple, streamlined gameplay" being ruined by upgrade point systems. And as someone who first got into FPS games back in those "retro" days, I can tell you that, contrary to what many devs seem to think, the fun of it didn't come from managing an entire bloody economy of upgrade currencies, or customizing your character to look like a damn unicorn...

But to be fair, Core Decay looks like it's trying to be a bit different, not explicitly "retro" or a "revival of the good ol' shooters." 
Retro As An Art Style 
Is perfectly valid IMO, I think we're already at the point where the market is now getting saturated with retro fps games (like back in the 90's), and in order to stand out we're going to see some games needing to innovate on the fps standard so they can stand out from the competition (again, like in the 90's).
Also, games like this did exist in the day, like Strife for example. 
Fair Post Stroggo. 
I personally don't mind RPG-lite upgrades / customisation as long as it's fairly simple / streamlined. But for a shooter it shouldn't get in the way of the...Core gameplay.

If, say, you've got character upgrade runes, character upgrade crystals, armour upgrade tokens, weapon alt-fire upgrades, and then extra upgrades for those alt-fire modes, oh and ship upgrade things....that might be far too much twatting around. Especially when half of those upgrades usually relate to tinkering with 3 off-hand weapon additions, 3 melee modes, or the 3 additional movement options. THAT would be a whole lot of unnecessary bloat. 
Yep, You Smashed It, Shambler. 
For a game about a "Doom Slayer," in some ways it feels more like "Demonic Invasion Defense Management Simulator"... though I doubt even most manager sims are as over-complicated. It gets really tiring to keep track of all that BS. That's why I've spent so little time playing Doom Eternal this past year and FAR more time playing Quake mods from this fine community.

As for Strife, it's not representative of most FPS's in the '90's, since it was an RPG. It probably wasn't until Bioshock that OCRUD became popular in FPS games, though Bioshock was also an RPG. Mixing genres isn't necessarily what I'd call "innovation," but Bioshock was popular, so I guess the money talked.

A lot of people like the RPG genre, and that's fine. But it's never been my cup of tea... Ultima Underworld convinced me of that. I love exploration and non-linear environments, but I don't like spending huge amounts of time on tedious/boring/non-shootery stuff (like talking to NPC's, "grinding," character customization, etc.) For an FPS, especially a "retro" one, I think that stuff should be left as window-dressing at most, not a core gameplay element.

Apocryph would've been a great retro-esque FPS in the vein of Heretic, if only it had been released in a more finished state, and with better level design and animation. 
 
https://selewi.itch.io/aske

Experience once again the first person shooter feeling in the same way you experienced it back in the '90s. A creation inspired by classics of the genre like Quake, Hexen, Unreal, and many others.

Gameplay video courtesy of some edgelord YouTube cretin.

Some more choice quotes from the developer:

Some of the models and textures took me more than 20 hours to make

There's a lot of love and effort in the project and it wasn't rushed at all. The demo took almost a year to be developed


ASKE is NOT a low effort project, and there's a lot of research behind the scenes in order to make it feel welcoming to retro enthusiasts without sacrificing the benefits of modern tech.

Opinions??? 
PS. 
Even the usual """boomer shooter""" audience is beginning to catch on:

On the one hand we have maps like Tears of the False God for free, on the other hand we have levels that look like the first test map done in Trenchbroom, that they (eventually) want money for... 
Mmmm... 
Explosive meatballs that emit red smoke...

Overall, a little too Minecrafty for my tastes. Textures lack detail, monsters look like they were modelled by a kid with Blender. Doesn't look low-poly in a "we were constrained by 90's tech limits" but more in a "we just didn't give a f---" way.

But hey, at least it's not an "asset flip," right? 
First | Previous | Next | Last
You must be logged in to post in this thread.
Website copyright © 2002-2020 John Fitzgibbons. All posts are copyright their respective authors.