> It seems they've forgotten
For a long time it's not the same company anymore, and the gaming landscape has changed considerably.
> it captured that horror atmosphere really well.
For first couple of times it was cool, but very quickly it turned in literally monster closets - pick up that item, suddenly wall opens and imp jumps at you! Scary!!
> and Eternal are a little too bright (almost cartoony)
I felt that about Eternal too. I played up to 5th mission and never returned to it. The constant "rip and tear" and related memes, along with overabundance of "doom music kicks in" with constant use and mention of "BFG Division" track sure gets grating.
There's an article called "What Doom Is Not" which I quite liked - https://scar3crow.com/2016/06/what-doom-is-not/