Func_Msgboard: All Time Top 10 FPS?

Posted by underworldfan on 2003/04/29 12:45:44

Here is a simple idea which could be interesting:
List your Top ten favorite FPS games of All time. Based on both SP and/or DM gameplay.
My list:

1.Quake
2.Doom
3.Quake 3 Arena
4.Duke Nukem 3d
5.Sin
6.Quake 2
7.Half-Life
8.Unreal Tournament
9.Unreal
10.Hexen

You can tell 1 thing from my list:
I dont care much for "realistic" FPS. Although for some reason i did like "Sin".

First | Previous | Next | Last

Bah

#1 posted by wrath on 2003/04/29 13:06:37

there has not been 10 games good enough to be listed...

1. quake1
2. metroid prime
3. deus ex
4. halo
5. half-life
6. unreal

Hmm

#2 posted by nonentity on 2003/04/29 13:52:36

I`d contest that Metroid Prime is in fact an FPS (in the `shooter` sense of the word anyway)

Nonentity.

#3 posted by wrath on 2003/04/29 13:55:16

what?! have you even played the game?

You shoot.
In first person.

ergo;

it is a FPS.

B00

#4 posted by Auhsan on 2003/04/29 13:57:56

1. Quake (the best)
2. Quake 3 Arena (+ CPMA :P)
3. Doom2 (new guns and monsters added a lot to the game)
4. Doom
5. Half-life (It was a great innovation to FPS, but it has been the cause of FPS being boring nowadays IMO)
6. Wolf3d (for its stupid final bosses :)
7. Serious Sam (Coop rocks)

Im searching for deus ex right now, I havent played it yet.

Hmm

#5 posted by nonentity on 2003/04/29 14:05:16

1. Quake 2
2. Half Life
3. Golden Eye
4. Unreal
5. Quake 1
6. Unreal Tournament
7. Deus Ex (Yes, I`m aware my previous post works for this too, shut up).
8. Time Splitters 2
9. Elite Force
10. Daikatana/Duke Nukem 3D (Kinda equal worth in my mind)

Hmm

#6 posted by nonentity on 2003/04/29 14:06:38

Yes, but it`s not a shooter game in the purest sense, given that you merely press lock on and then fire for the shooting bits (look, I was just being pedantic, fuck off).

#7 posted by H-Hour on 2003/04/29 14:59:29

I havent played too many FPS games, so my list will be short.

1. Ghost Recon (I like realism)
2. Halo
3. Quake 1

11. UT (good, but not top-10 good)

Odd, I didnt even include the only game I mapped for.

Uhohhh...

#8 posted by Gom Jabbar on 2003/04/29 15:13:45

... I hope Aardappel doesn't read this thread ;).

System Shock 2

#9 posted by R.P.G. on 2003/04/29 15:24:45

nuff said.

Honestly, I don't understand the fascination with sorting things into top 10 lists. Half the time people will post immediately after and say "Whoa I forgot XYZ!! But I had ten on my list, so what do I do?!" This just emphasizes the point that you can't really create a good top 10 list, since people change their minds immediately afterward.

It Goes To 11

#10 posted by spentron on 2003/04/29 15:57:26

1 Quake
2 Quake 3 Arena
3 Cube
4 Duke 3D
5 Half-Life
6 Alien vs. Predator (1)
7 Quake 2
8 Unreal
9 DooM
10 UT
11 Alien vs. Predator (Jaguar)

And yes Cube is there because I really like it that much. May be giving it a slight nudge since it`s "short" although this is offset by easy creation. Note, qmap oldtimers, 8 months ago it would have been #11.

Jury`s still out on Serious Sam and maybe I`ll try full Undying and Alice and maybe Elite Force or WOT. Based on demos, it`s unlikely I`ll be trying more NOLFs, SysShocks, Thiefs, or Deus Ex. I`m not sure Descent counts, and I know FP robot games don`t.

R.P.G.

#11 posted by Kell on 2003/04/29 15:58:37

yeah, I don't like the Top10 idea - for anything.
gosh, you are very sage these days :P

Nonentity

#12 posted by wrath on 2003/04/29 16:37:15

sure.

Heres My List Fag0t

#13 posted by inertia on 2003/04/29 16:41:14

1. Quake

Ok Then

#14 posted by Maric on 2003/04/29 16:44:54

My list of the best...
Quake2
Quake
Half Life
Alien vs, Predator2
UT - CTF only
Soldier Of Fortune1
Doom/Doom2
Unreal1/Return To Na Pali
Red Faction
Serious Sam1/2

Good but gets boring fast...
Elite Force
BF1942
CS

Some of the worst (just my opinion of course)...
UT2003K
UT2
MOHAA - I did enjoy some of the SP
RTCW
SOF2
JK2
Q3

Let Me See

#15 posted by Abyss on 2003/04/29 18:05:08

Quake (and mission packs)
Quake III (and Team Arena)
Quake II (and mission packs)
RTCW
Half Life
DooM (all)
Descent I,II

hmmm,.....My brain hurts, ...that's it

Ffs

#16 posted by wrath on 2003/04/29 18:24:10

thief!

...

#17 posted by underworldfan on 2003/04/29 20:51:43

i forgot about Cube. :/

Which i love, obviously.

Goldeneye is good too, yes indeedy.

...

#18 posted by necros on 2003/04/29 21:30:28

System Shock 2
Quake
Descent 2
Unreal

no top ten, but these are my favourites anyway...

Bleh Top 10 Thread...

#19 posted by Vodka on 2003/04/29 22:24:35

& Etc.

#20 posted by Shambler on 2003/04/30 00:39:55

1= Quake
1= Unreal
1= Battlezone2

that`s all....most of the rest are good but those three are the ones that have really made a mark with me

...

#21 posted by pope on 2003/04/30 00:56:01

Ken`s Labyrinth

Spentron...

#22 posted by Shambler on 2003/04/30 02:14:57

Undying and WOT are both great. Alice is good too but not quite as satisfying despite the cool themes and music.

IMHO.

Roughly...

#23 posted by Aardappel on 2003/04/30 04:27:44

(too late Gom :)

1. Doom 1/2
2. QuakeWorld
3. Cube
4. Descent 1/2
5. Quake
6. Serious Sam 1/2
7. Jedi Knight 1
8. KISS Psycho circus
9. Unreal 1
A. Dark Forces
B. Metroid Prime
C. Heretic 1
D. Quake 3
E. Quake 2

Top Ten

#24 posted by GibFest on 2003/04/30 07:01:28

1. Quake
2. BF1942 (Desert Combat)
3. MOHAA
4. NOLF
5. Goldeneye (N64)
6. Red Faction
7. Half Life
8. Quake 3 Arena
9. Quake 2
10. Serious Sam

Pissing Shit

#25 posted by DaZ on 2003/04/30 10:38:05

1. Quake
2. Doom2
3. Halo
4. Unreal Tournament
5. Unreal
6. Aliens VS Predator
7. Aliens VS Predator 2
8. Duke Nukem 3D
9. Jedi Knight 2 (once u get the lightsabre!)
10. Deus Ex

First | Previous | Next | Last

You must be logged in to post in this thread.